Athanasius in Egypt in the 4th century was active in eliminating groups of ascetics that included women - endeavoring to direct syneisakts, or those living in 'spiritual marriage' as a vowed virgin with a priest back into their family households, not trusting that men and women could live together free of sexual distraction. This condemnation continued to see Eustathius of Sebaste brought before the Council of Gangra in the 340's for allowing women to deny 'male power over their heads'. Basil of Caesarea comes to reflect Athanasius' attitude in establishing his own monasteries - despite the influence of his sister, mother and grandmother and his acknowledgement of the teachings of Gregory of Nyssa on the non-gendered nature of the soul, his communities were segregated by sex.
Evidence in the Pachomian
koinonia suggests that the segregation of men and women became more strict through time, with women not allowed at all to visit male monastic communities, and male priests and deacons only visiting on Sunday and to bury the dead.
While the
Apophthegmata does privilege the sayings of Amma Theodora and Sarah and Syncletica, Syrian female ascetics were regarded as a danger to their male counterparts, and thus they were required to wear the veil. Accounts of saints such as Mary of Egypt and Pelagia dwell on their past as prostitutes - temptresses living in bodily sin, until they are rescued by benevolent male religious. Mary transcends gender in some ways - she is found in the desert, naked, burned black with white short hair, but becomes gendered via the return of the male. Pelagia ends her days in the monastery, in the guise of a eunuch.
These tantalising episodes of trancendence of gender disappear as women's roles are undermined by the likes of Jerome, writing in savage polemic against co-mingled communities. Letter 22 by Jerome is a vicious satire, a full expression of contempt against remnouth (a Coptic word for monastics with no fixed rule), declaring their utter delusion and their attempts to ordain women so as to gain freer access to them. He is equally damning of the sublimation of rich widow ascetics, with fine clothes and retinues of eunuchs as he is of virgins, whim he claims wear a cloak for their impure thoughts of sexual misconduct.
Jerome himself was beset by acute sexual fantasy, we see a true Freudian reaction formation in his demand that women and men stifle the temptation of the flesh. The introduction of a mythical centaur in his
Life of Paul the First Hermit might hint at a metaphor for his obsession with the semi-bestial nature of the human condition.
Letter 22 reveals Jerome's preoccupations - in describing the loss of virginity by women in their souls, he resorts to the grossest metaphors from Scripture - such women will be found opening their legs to all that pass by. In describing the enclosed existence that he recommends for Eustochium, a young woman destined to become an enclosed virginal nun, he articulates her undefiled wait as the Bride of Christ thus:
'When sleep overcomes you, he will come behind the wall, will thrust his hand through the aperture and will caress your belly; and you will start up all trembling and will cry, 'I am wounded with love'.'
In works after Letter 22, Jerome flatters his own circle, which had decisively renounced femininity. When he and Paula arrived in Bethelehem, it was to set up segregated communities, and Paula was particularly influenced on this, not even allowing eunuchs as servants. Strict enclosure and the status of Bride of Christ, awaiting her Bridegroom was the norm for nuns, by the 5th century.
We are given small reprieve. Augustine of Hippo composed a rule for monks in the fourth century and is believed to have given a gender-altered text of the same material to a community of women. The rule is a gentle one, and in later writings Augustine does recognise that there is a point beyond which female ascetics do not require male tutelage any more.
Another intriguing text comes from Evagrius of Ponticus - in his
Sentences to a Virgin, which was written to deaconess Severa in Melania's community, we see that despite his Origenist background, Evagrius was somewhat the misogynist, taking a gendered view of religious life. In Evagrius' eyes, women were spiritually and intellectually incapable of achieving gnosis. They were limited to 'illumination' - which, in a way, is significant in itself, given Evagrius' mysticism of light.
The candle of culture burns bright and hard, even in the ones who speak with rarefied tongue.