Ab initio, et ante saecula creata sum, et usque ad futurum saeculum non desinam, et in habitione sancte coram ipso ministravi.

From the beginning and before the world was I created, and unto the end of the world to come I shall not cease to be, and in the holy dwelling place I have ministered before Him.

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Ch 1 - Evagrius of Pontus - The Emergence of Monasticism by Marilyn Dunn

Bishop Timothy Ailouros becomes the master of deception when, in order to identify heterodox ascetics and Manichaeans, he allows monks and clerics to eat meat on Sundays. For Manichaeans, in particular, meat was strictly forbidden. The theme, this idea that there was 'false gnosis' in the teachings of some of the demiurgic and docetic doctrines, and so identification of the followers of such insidious propaganda had to be identified and ousted, is well represented in the work of Evagrius of Pontus.

Evagrius of Pontus was a monk of Kellia, arguably the most notable among monastic theorists of the fourth century. His works include Sentences to a Virgin, Antirhektikos, Of the Eight Evil Thoughts, On Prayer, Praktikos, Gnostikos, and Kephalia Gnostica.


Evagrius delivers gnomic, imperative, Stoic-style sentences, designed for meditation. The monastic (nous monachos) who subdues all passions is rewarded with gnosis of God. Steps are given beginning from the contemplation of God's creation through to actually contemplating God himself, and the soul must be purged and refined through constant vigilance, examination of thoughts and exercise of virtues. Fear of God is purported to strengthen faith, which in turn is strengthened by enkrateia (asceticism). Abstinence is made unshakeable by perseverance and hope, and from these is born the absence of passion (apatheia) whose offspring is charity (agape). Following charity is natural knowledge, theology, and the praktike gives way to hesychia, which melts into gnosis of God.

Evagrius is hostile to thoughts (logismoi), and these must be discovered and purged (as per the Desert Fathers) to make the soul healthy. He identifies a sequence, in more than one text, of the Eight Evil Thoughts, which he identifies arise in sequence - gluttony, fornication, avarice, sadness, anger, accedia (listlessness), vainglory and pride. He applies remedies to these faults based on the tripartite nature of the soul and Galen's theory of curing by opposites - fasting restrains lust, love counters avarice and depression, anger is countered by gentleness, compassion and charity, accedia needs tears, perseverance and vigilance, vainglory and pride require humility and sober past rememberance. The achievement of apatheia releases the nous of the monk to the highest state known on earth, union with God. These ideas are returned to western monasticism through John Cassian with his seven deadly sins.

Evagrius was a valued pedagogue - this was no reduction of eremitic asceticism into dry intellectual schema - but was the fruit of praktike. Theophilus, bishop of Alexandria, unsuccessfully tries to offer Evagrius the bishopric of Thmuis. Evagruis had experience of the soul being illuminated in prayer, and was actually troubled by this light, to the extent that he sought advice by travelling to John of Lycopolis. They form the conclusion that through apatheia, the soul's own light begins to show, as a prelude to being bathed in the light of the Holy Trinity, of the Son of the un-seeable Father.

Evagrius dies in 399 as Theophilus of Alexandria begins expelling hundreds of monks from Nitria and Scetis, for following Origen and denying that God can be visualised in human form. This was a political move, his real targets were the Tall Brothers, Eusebius and Euthymios who had been his oikonomoi in Alexandria and had exposed corruption in the church. Origenist ideas were ironically strengthened amonst the community of exiles that then forms in Palestine, but Evagrius' works remain mostly sidelined, figuring quietly in the History of the Monks of Egypt.

The Hidden History of Women's Ordination: Female Clergy in the Medieval West by Gary Macy

Oh. Wow. Time to save up some espresso dollars to buy this one, I think......




"The Hidden History of Women’s Ordination: Female Clergy in the Medieval West offers valuable historical background for the ongoing debate about women’s ordination. Theologian and historian Gary Macy documents and explains references to the ordination of women that exist in papal and church documents in the first millennium of Christianity.

As a radical church reform that occurred during the 11th and 12th centuries took hold, it changed the concept of ordination, leaving women behind. But prior to that, sufficient evidence exists to warrant the claim that women were considered to be ordained ministers in the Western church.

Macy writes that women were not ordained as ordination would come to be understood from the 12th century on, “that is, as receiving a personal irrevocable power to serve at the altar.” Rather, he writes, “They were commissioned for particular roles in particular communities.” The important point to be made, however, is that so were men."
- National Catholic Reporter



http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0195189701/ref=olp_product_details?ie=UTF8&me=&seller=





Saturday, January 23, 2010

From the Second Censing, 1962 Roman Missal:

Pone, Domine, custodiam ori meo, et ostium circumstantiae labiis meis.
Ut non declinet cor meum in verbo malitiae, ad excusandas in peccatis.

Set a watch, O Lord, before my mouth, and a door round about my lips.
Incline not my heart to evil words: to make excuses in sins.

Friday, January 22, 2010

Ch 1 - Control, Self Will and Society - The Emergence of Monasticism by Marilyn Dunn

Control

St Antony's spiritual framwork required that the monk subdue his body in order that his soul may be freed from passion, and united with God. The monk was to battle the demons and angels that warred over his body/mind, and was to master the bodily urges for food and sex which, unconquered, risked separating him from communion with the divine.

Women and children were recognised as temptations, and part of the rationale for the flight to the desert was to escape or shift away from their earthly presence. There were various methods taught in aid of controlling the sex drive - working to the point of fatigue was one, but the most interesting from my view was the primary method used, that of controlling food intake. Following Greek medicine, the idea was that the body, with it's four humors, blood, black bile, yellow bile and phelgm needed to be dried out, so that it produced less semen, and precipitated impotence. Meat was considered to be the primary source of moist humors, and was therefore banned. So was sleep, because sleep was 'moistening'. Other theories included the notion that the body burned with innate heat, so only cooling foods should be ingested.

Self-Will and it's Renunciation

In Nitria, the location of the 'best known' monasteries of all of Egypt, life was not conducted in complete solitude, and the the wisdom of elders and their 'miraculous powers' were passed to younger ascetics through personal instruction and example. The Apophthegamata Patrum is a collection the works of many of the Fathers who possessed a gift of the word. These words seem to have been worthy currency - when Apa Or was asked for a word, he instructed Apa Sisoes to follow him in everything that he did, insisting that he himself was inferior to all men. The self abnegation of the monks and their endurance purchased for them a life of total detachment and tranquility. But the apa-disciple relationship was a formative part of this monastic virtue-  only by completely relinquishing self will could spiritual progress be made.

There's the overly quotable story of Apa Lot and Apa Joseph, of course. Lot asks:

'Apa, as far as I can I say my little office, I fast a little, I pray and meditate, I live in peace and as far as I can, I purify my thoughts. What else can I do?' The old man stood up and stretched his hands toward heaven. His fingers became like ten lamps of fire and he said to him, 'If you will, you can become all flame'.

As the fame of the monks grew, they attracted more and more visitors - Apa Arsenius turns away a 'virgin of senatorial rank'; who came from Rome with a cry:

'I pray God to take the rememberance of you from my heart.'

Wow. I guess that sort of statement was the rough equivalent of letting the air out of all of the tyres of your exes car in 4th century Egypt.

Ascetics kept a particular blanket for use in the reception of visitors. Over time, the monks became living monuments of a sort, with people travelling many hundreds of miles in pilgrimage to visit them. I love this paragraph from Dunn, p20:

'Ascetic behaviour itself is performative by nature and some of monasticisms most complex interactions with non-ascetic society, such as the numerous dramas of exorcism performed by Antony and other spiritual athletes, created a bridge between Christians and pagans, offering a powerful demonstration of the truths of the new religion.'

Demonology was universal in this community - pagans had both good and evil demons, whereas Christians only had evil demons, that inhabited the body and caused pride, weariness, levity and aggression, amongst other things. Exorcisms restored the boundaries of what was good and and clean and what, well, wasn't.

The charisma and self marginalisation of the ascetics added to their intermediary power in gifts of clairvoyance in the eyes of a non-ascetic society, and we see Symeon Stylites, for example, draw remarkable crowds by living atop a pillar outside Antioch for several decades.

Ch 1 - Manichaeanism - The Emergence of Monasticism by Marilyn Dunn

Manichaean missionaries in Egypt in CE 270 offered an answer to that all-time troubling question - if God is good, why is there evil in the world? Manichaeanism purported that man is rooted in both darkness and light, but Jesus controls the mechanism for distilling light from within all humankind, and when he accomplishes his work the universe will be burnt, and all light will be refined. Mani himself had originally been an Elkasite, but left the sect to develop the work of Marcion and the concept of a docetic Christ.

Intermediate beings were transposed between God and the cosmos in Manichaeanism, including an evil demiurge who had created the earth, providing an answer to the problems of theodicy and the existence of evil on earth. Christ brought a hidden knowledge, a gnosis, that offered redemption to the initiate. Platonism is evident in both Origenist and Manichaean cosmology, both affirming the grossness of the material world and the possibility of ascent of the soul to God through transformational asceticism. Both the Christian demiurgics (Manichaeans) and St Antony taught gnosis, and the manistanan, the shelters for the Manichaean elect, closely resembled the orthodox monasteries of the c.320.

St Antony's anachoresis as touted by Athanasius - the retreat from the village to the tombs to the outer and then the remote 'Inner Mountain' - became a symbolic trajectory for monks right up to St Jerome, who himself divides monastic life into three classes - the hermit, the cenobite and the remnuoth, those apoptactics who were particularly despised:

'The third class is that which they call remnuoth, a very inferior and despised type...They dwell together by twos and threes, not many more, and live according to their own will and independently. They contribute to a common fund part of their earnings,  that they may have a general store of food. But they live for the most part in cities and fortified towns' (I like the sound of these characters).

Athanasius made the desert into a city for his monks, who 'registered themselves for citizenship of the heavens'. A settlement grew on the Mount of Nitria, the first monk to settle there is Amoun in 315. The transmission of ascetic ideas initially depended on the culture of the word rather than written instructions, so communities quickly formed around teachers. Amoun was not fond of this phenomenon however, and retreats further south to set up what became known as 'Kellia', literally, the 'cells'. This starts a imitation chain, which sees the History of the Monks of Egypt, written in the 390's, make the claim that there was 'no town in Egypt or the Thebaid which was not surrounded by hermitages, 'as if by walls''. The cells were built from mud bricks, and for famous anchorites they would be furnished with all luxuries, even including a well. Some hermit colonies did build a church for communal worship on Sundays, but the main practice of the monks was hesychia, solitary prayer, recitation of palms and meditation in their cell.

Daily desert life was meditation on the scriptures, (melete), psalmody and labour. Apa Lucius has a beautiful story of how he develops an earthly practice of praying without ceasing:

'By working and praying all day long, I can complete around sixteen baskets. I give away two of these to any beggar who comes to my door. I make my living from the rest. And the man who receives the gift of two baskets prays for me...That is how, by God's grace, I manage to pray without ceasing'.

The monks of Nitria lived alone or in small groups which acknowledged group identity by repeating the psalmody at the same hours and in communal worship - the synaxis, holy nights of Saturday and Sunday. Ascetics might employ an oikonomos, or steward, to sell their crafts, and the communities of Scetis and Kellia both created a xenodocheion, for the reception of visitors and care of the sick.

Wednesday, January 20, 2010

Ch 1 - Asceticism - The Emergence of Monasticism by Marilyn Dunn

Dunn walks us a little further through Origen's cosmology in describing the birth of the Western ascetic movement. Origen interprets 'the soul of all flesh is blood' as implying that the creation of Adam brought forth two levels of Adam - a spiritual Adam made in the image of God and a hylic Adam. Within the human body there was considered to be real evidence of the divine, in the shape of the soul, and the body was where the divine and the material merged (as per Stoic philosophy). Transformative asceticism begins here.

Transformation in asceticism is often defined in terms of rejection - of sex, of food, of the social order as it would otherwise be known in the cultural epoch of the ascetic. Sexual asceticism was most common in Egypt at the end of the fourth century - in Syria the Christian church itself at this time was radically encratite (from Greek enkrateia, continence). The principle that sexuality was really part of the animal world and the sexual act causes loss of Spirit meant that the ihidaya, or celibate, was regarded as elite. It was considered possible to maintain chastity in marriage - The Acts of Thomas describes a young couple who do not consummate their marriage but dedicate themselves to Christ.

The Gospel of Thomas proposes a goal of a more radical self-transformation:

'When you make the two one and when you make the inside like the outside and the outside like the inside and the above like the below and whenyou make the male and the female one and the same, so that the male be not male nor the female, female; and you fashion eyes in place of an eye and a hand in the place of a hand and a foot in place of a foot and a likeness in place of a likeness.....'

The transformed body is genderless, consistent and singular. Singularity brings prizes not granted to others:

' Many are standing at the door, but it is the solitary who will enter the bridal chamber'.

St Antony writes of much the same:

' The Holy Spirit also gives them control over their souls and bodies in order that both may be sanctified and inherit together'.

Ihidaya in Syriac, is translated into monachos, in Coptic. Monk, as we know the word, therefore may imply a oneness of being, a unity derived out of self transformation.

Anachoresis

Monachos also has a root of 'monos', the solitary, and St Antony practices extreme anachoresis by removing himself further and further from human society and habitation. Individual renunciants - 'apotactics', or celibates who had adopted a distinctive style of dress and lived in community houses and 'syneisakts', women who lived a life of chastity had been prevalent in Alexandria for a good time prior to St Antony - but as a monachos he decisively removed himself from society, severing social connection and renouncing all property (which was not typical for apotactics or syneisakts).

Bishop Athanasius

Is the hagiographer of St Antony, writing as he struggled against the theology of Arianism. He was exiled five times from his diocese in Alexandria because of this opposition to the emperor-favoured Arianism, and one of his main purposes in chronicling the Life of St Antony was to hold Antony up as an icon of sorts - Athanasius sets up Antony's attacks by demons as the fear of death, which he reports Antony wards off with the sign of the cross. By portraying Antony as unlettered, Athanasius advances a Christology that is natural, as opposed to philoophical or learned wisdom.

Athanasius spent much of his early episcopacy amongst the desert monastics, and his own purpose in narrative is to incorporate this already existing movement, by definition opposed to the present norms in his society, into the official church. While Athanasius did not favour the use of relics, his Life of Antony proclaims himself as custodian of a cloak and two sheepskins of Antony's, so he becomes guardian of Antony's posthumous charisma. Athanasius sets up the desert as a place that is free from the burden of riches and taxes, a place that is really well, separate from the groups of Hieracas, his, um, arch rival.

Monday, January 18, 2010

Ch 1 - The Emergence of Christian Eremitism - The Emergence of Monasticism by Marilyn Dunn

And into the desert we go.

This chapter begins by asking the question why individuals from the second century and beyond in Roman Egypt sought to separate themselves from the rest of their known community and devote themselves, utterly, to the religious life? Suggestions have arisen by scholars over time and include an opinion that it was a response to the imperial adoption of Christianity, that it was a simple continuation of a Jewish ascetic tradition well established by the Essenes and the Therapeutae, and interestingly, that it was a reflection of the economic crises of the times. This last observation is purported to be supported by the term anachoresis, which means not only a retreat into religious life, but also a flight from tax obligations, in it's original usage.

A short review of the life of St Anthony (d. 356CE) is then offered. St Anthony, once a wealthy young farmer, takes the advice from the Gospels to sell all that he possesses and gives to the poor, in pursuit of the treasure of Heaven. At 35 years of age, St. Anthony retreats to the fringes of the village and eventually removes himself to the 'inner mountain', a life of severe asceticism and prayer. The ideals of dispossession, solitude and austerity become the locus of Western monasticism with the communication of the Seven Letters of Anthony, where gnosis is offered to the hardy ascetic:

'Those who know themselves, know their time, and are not moved by diverse tongues'.

Repentance of the spirit, the mind and every member of the body results in a return to the original state, that state where one may aspire to union with God.

St Anthony's theology is maintained within an Origenist cosmology. In this framework, before the creation of the world, all beings were equal and chose by their own actions whether they were to be saved, or to be damned. Souls were considered to have originally been intelligences that had free will, but which grew cold in charity and then fell away from God, to become angels, human souls or devils. Human souls are deliberately in the middle, there, it was considered that angels and demons did war over the province of the soul.

Biblical inspiration shines through St Anthony's letters in the soteriological role of Christ - Anthony understands the parousia (presence of Christ) to be both the spiritual message of humanities third chance to redeem itself, and return to God (the second having been obeying the commandments of Moses) and the historical message in the 'Spirit of Adoption' of Jesus' life.

These Origenist and biblical ideas reflect the fostering of the theological and philosophical ideas of Alexandria in the khora - the cultivated countryside along the length of the Nile. The ability of St Anthony and other ascetics to read the complex works of Origen has been questioned - it is likely that they have absorbed these ideas in diluted or second hand form.

Sunday, January 17, 2010

The Emergence of Monasticism by Marilyn Dunn



The Emergence of Monasticism: From the Desert Fathers to the Early Middle
Ages. By Marilyn Dunn. (Malden, Massachusetts: Blackwell. 2000. Pp. viii,
280. $64.95.)

This book represents the beginning of my journey into the history of monasticism in the West. Marilyn Dunn is a graduate of Edinburgh University and a Senior Lecturer in Medieval History at the University of Glasgow. In subject matter the book itself betrays the author's scholarly background, with a review by Tim Vivian published in The Catholic Historical Review (2001)  highlighting the fact that the emphasis is Western, with half the book historically oriented to the time of St Benedict or later. There is also one chapter on Britain and Ireland and another on monasticism in England post-7th century, and a large amount of name and place nomination as description, so I may not be so faithful when it comes to chronicling a journey through this book in the later chapters.

Because I am far from a scholar, and because my background knowledge of this field is minimal to shrinking, I will not be offering a critical read of this book - moreso, I intend to record my thoughts and observations about the content as I travel through it. It may, very quickly, begin to look like a terminology dictionary, we shall see.

References

Dunn, M. (2000). The Emergence of Monasticism: From the Desert Fathers to the Early Middle
Ages. Malden, Massachusetts: Blackwell.

Vivian, T. (2001). The Emergence of Monasticism: From the Desert Fathers to the Early Middle Ages (review) The Catholic Historical Review - Volume 87, Number 4, pp. 714-715