Ab initio, et ante saecula creata sum, et usque ad futurum saeculum non desinam, et in habitione sancte coram ipso ministravi.

From the beginning and before the world was I created, and unto the end of the world to come I shall not cease to be, and in the holy dwelling place I have ministered before Him.

Monday, July 5, 2010

Ch 3 - Segregation - The Emergence of Monasticism by Marilyn Dunn

Athanasius in Egypt in the 4th century was active in eliminating groups of ascetics that included women - endeavoring to direct syneisakts, or those living in 'spiritual marriage' as a vowed virgin with a priest back into their family households, not trusting that men and women could live together free of sexual distraction. This condemnation continued to see Eustathius of Sebaste brought before the Council of Gangra in the 340's for allowing women to deny 'male power over their heads'. Basil of Caesarea comes to reflect Athanasius' attitude in establishing his own monasteries - despite the influence of his sister, mother and grandmother and his acknowledgement of the teachings of Gregory of Nyssa on the non-gendered nature of the soul, his communities were segregated by sex.

Evidence in the Pachomian koinonia suggests that the segregation of men and women became more strict through time, with women not allowed at all to visit male monastic communities, and male priests and deacons only visiting on Sunday and to bury the dead.

While the Apophthegmata does privilege the sayings of Amma Theodora and Sarah and Syncletica, Syrian female ascetics were regarded as a danger to their male counterparts, and thus they were required to wear the veil. Accounts of saints such as Mary of Egypt and Pelagia dwell on their past as prostitutes - temptresses living in bodily sin, until they are rescued by benevolent male religious. Mary transcends gender in some ways - she is found in the desert, naked, burned black with white short hair, but becomes gendered via the return of the male. Pelagia ends her days in the monastery, in the guise of a eunuch.

These tantalising episodes of trancendence of gender disappear as women's roles are undermined by the likes of Jerome, writing in savage polemic against co-mingled communities. Letter 22 by Jerome is a vicious satire, a full expression of contempt against remnouth (a Coptic word for monastics with no fixed rule), declaring their utter delusion and their attempts to ordain women so as to gain freer access to them. He is equally damning of the sublimation of rich widow ascetics, with fine clothes and retinues of eunuchs as he is of virgins, whim he claims wear a cloak for their impure thoughts of sexual misconduct.

Jerome himself was beset by acute sexual fantasy, we see a true Freudian reaction formation in his demand that women and men stifle the temptation of the flesh. The introduction of a mythical centaur in his Life of Paul the First Hermit might hint at a metaphor for his obsession with the semi-bestial nature of the human condition.

Letter 22 reveals Jerome's preoccupations - in describing the loss of virginity by women in their souls, he resorts to the grossest metaphors from Scripture - such women will be found opening their legs to all that pass by. In describing the enclosed existence that he recommends for Eustochium, a young woman destined to become an enclosed virginal nun, he articulates her undefiled wait as the Bride of Christ thus:

'When sleep overcomes you, he will come behind the wall, will thrust his hand through the aperture and will caress your belly; and you will start up all trembling and will cry, 'I am wounded with love'.'

In works after Letter 22, Jerome flatters his own circle, which had decisively renounced femininity. When he and Paula arrived in Bethelehem, it was to set up segregated communities, and Paula was particularly influenced on this, not even allowing eunuchs as servants. Strict enclosure and the status of Bride of Christ, awaiting her Bridegroom was the norm for nuns, by the 5th century.

We are given small reprieve. Augustine of Hippo composed a rule for monks in the fourth century and is believed to have given a gender-altered text of the same material to a community of women. The rule is a gentle one, and in later writings Augustine does recognise that there is a point beyond which female ascetics do not require male tutelage any more.

Another intriguing text comes from Evagrius of Ponticus - in his Sentences to a Virgin, which was written to deaconess Severa in Melania's community, we see that despite his Origenist background, Evagrius was somewhat the misogynist, taking a gendered view of religious life. In Evagrius' eyes, women were spiritually and intellectually incapable of achieving gnosis. They were limited to 'illumination' - which, in a way, is significant in itself, given Evagrius' mysticism of light.


The candle of culture burns bright and hard, even in the ones who speak with rarefied tongue.

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

Sophia - Above and Below

 
In Part B of his paper entitled ‘The Jewish Background of the Gnostic Sophia Myth’, Macrae highlights the consistent appearance in Valentinianism of the higher and the lower Sophia, and the variable means of her fall. On some occasions she desires to imitate the Father by producing her own emanations without the knowledge or consent of her consort, and thus she falls, in other instances her fall is derived from her action, of seeking to comprehend the Father, perfectly.

In the Apocryphon of James I we see a role for the higher Sophia, where she is graced to be the revealer-redeemer of spiritual men, and the lower, who is the author of evil (corroborated by Irenaeus I. 21.5). The name Achamoth is used for the lower Sophia. The distinction is repeated in the Gospel of Philip:

‘Echamoth is one and Echmoth is another. Echamoth is simply Sophia, but Echmoth is the Sophia of death, she being the one who knows death.’

These two roles of Sophia,  She who un-veils life, and She who is of the cloak of death, captures a strong sense of the essence of her nature, in my opinion.

The Gospel of Truth does not directly refer to a Sophia character, rather the abstract ‘Plane’ is invoked, where she grows powerful through a fog of anguish, fashioning her own matter in emptiness, counterfeiting the world of the Pleroma. Here Plane performs a double duty, in the abstract, for the mythological Sophia and Demiurge characters. The distinction between the life-giving wisdom of the Jewish literature and a dualistic double and shining Pleroma is starkly apparent, here.

In Part C, the Jewish attitude to beneficient Wisdom, residing in Israel, is contrasted to the Gnostic Sophia-Wisdom by Macrae, Sophia-Wisdom who is synonymously the good revealer and the hapless creator, the despised source of all evil matter, the one who falls. Macrae then proposes that a revolt within Judaism is responsible for the incursion of this Gnostic attitude to Wisdom – a growth in realisation, perhaps, that the Wisdom of Yahweh might actually be a deception.  Hence the Wisdom literature descent of Sophia (Gen 1:2b and 1 Enoch 62) becomes a fall, in the esoteric Gnostic account of the creation myth. Macrae proposes a kind of backward read of the fall of Eve, in the creation of the Gnostic myths, where a fall in the Pleroma was, in a way, the fall of man, an inferior copy of such. Gnostic midrash indeed perverts the intention of the OT story, and Macrae provides the example of the the Ap. John where the idea that the fall of man was actually beneficial was proposed, since the fall was an attempt to liberate him from the power of the Archons.
I found the voice Macrae speaks with in this paper to be a little regimented and dogmatic when he discussed Gnostic myth – whether this is a true reflection of the material, or to a greater extent  his own perspective and opinion on the early Gnostics remains to be argued by someone with deeper realisation of either, than myself. I greatly appreciate the different perspectives on Sophia in the Gnostic texts that I will now carry with me as I read the NHL scripture, in the future. To a certain extent I don’t think that the feeling-of-stepping-backwards-but-at-the-same-time-a-sensed-glimpses-of-a-more-encompassing-truth, that wells in me when I read these texts, will be in any way resolved.

In the completely un-contextualised words of Fr Tim+, this may well imply that it’s a rather perfect time to say:

 ‘Good. That means it’s working’.
  

Ref:
Macrae, GW. (1970). The Jewish Background of the Gnostic Sophia Myth, Novum Testamentum, 12:2, 86-101.

Monday, June 28, 2010

Sophia - the Jewish Gnostic nexus

'The Jewish Background of the Gnostic Sophia Myth' – reflections on a paper by George Macrae, 1970 (reference is below).

An oft-proposed tenet in scholarly discourse, when discussing Sophia, is that Sophia is a Gnostic adaptation of the Wisdom figure of Jewish scripture. This paper seeks to take into account the Sethian-Ophite writings that are deigned  as Gnostic, found in the documents of the Coptic Nag Hammadi library, as well as writings that are characterised as being of Valentinian Gnostic extraction. Parallels are drawn between the Jewish Sophia and the Gnostic Sophia, and then an argument is drawn for the Jewish Origin of the Gnostic Sophia myth.

The parallels in Jewish and Gnostic sources: 


1) Sophia is personal:  
the Gnostic writings hypostatise Sophia to a greater extent than the Jewish writings, but she is ‘passim’ (here, there and everywhere) in each.


2) Sophia is joined in ultimate union with God:
She is breath, emanation, reflection and image (Wis 7:25-26)
She is the first of his creatures (Prov 8:22)
His companion (Prov 8:30)
In Gnostic scripture:
Sophia breathing power into creation is the favourite theme of the Gnostic cosmogonies. (On the Origin of the World)
Sophia is usually the first (‘Barbelo’ in Ap. John), or the only (Hypostasis of the Archons), and sometimes part of the Trinity – the Father, Sophia and the Son (The Sophia of Jesus Christ).


 3) Sophia was brought forth from the beginning:
(Prov 8:22, Sir. 1:4) In the Sophia of Jesus Christ, Sophia ‘the great’ is joined in syzygy with the second Aeon, the Father, ‘from the beginning’.


 4) Sophia dwells in the clouds:
(Sir 24:4 LXX Bar. 3:29) In On the Origin of the World we read ‘and no one was with him (Sabaoth) in the cloud except Sophia Pistis. In Ap. John Sophia conceals her horror child Ialdabaoth in a cloud of light. The ‘Holy Spirit who is called the mother of the living’ exists too in this cloud, perhaps as Sophia herself.


 5) Sophia attends to God’s throne or is herself enthroned:
(Wis. 9:4, 1 Enoch 84:3, Sir 24:4) Attending to the Old Testament throne of God in Jewish literature, Sophia is also seen in On the Origin of the World with Sabaoth on her right and Ialdabaoth on the left.


 6) Sophia is identified with a Holy Spirit:
(Wis. 7:7, 7:22). The Gnostics specifically identify Sophia with the Spirit of God, by interpreting Genesis 1:2 (the Spirit moving over the waters) as her repentance for her fall, for example in the Ap. John.


 7) Sophia was at least instrumental in the creation of the world:
(Prov. 3:19, 8:27) In neither Jewish nor Gnostic scripture does she create by herself.


 8) Sophia communicates wisdom and revelation to men:
(Wis. passim) In Gnostic sources, Sophia is responsible for the element of light in men.
Sophia is at all times an ambivalent figure in Gnosticism – through her fall she is blamed for the existence of evil matter, but because she belongs to a world of light she is credited with the presence of the Divine, or of the revelation of man.
An interesting statement is proposed here by Macrae – that creation and revelation are moral opposites for the Gnostic, one a tragedy, one redemption. He states that only in a schizophrenic, or ambivalent personality, can they both be the work of a single agent. Her voice, rebuking Ialdabaoth in the Hypostasis of the Archons resonates – for his boast ‘I am God and there is no other’.
The revealing function of Sophia is emphasised in the roles of Ennoia, Epinoia and Pronoia, behaving like the descending and ascending Wisdom of 1 Enoch, and in the hymnic ending of the Ap. John, where she is ‘the richness of the light’ ‘the thought of the Pleroma’ and ‘the perfect hypostasis of the All’ in a triple descent to awaken man from his deep sleep by communicating gnosis to him.


 9) Sophia descends into the world of men:
(1 Enoch 62:2) This prevails throughout Gnostic scripture, captured in Ap. John as Pronoia descends to bring revelation to men. Her descent is motivated by God’s providence in Jewish scripture (Sir. 24) but Gnostic sources typically assign a cosmic catastrophe to her presence, below.


 10) Sophia reascends to her celestial home:
(1 Enoch 62:2) Jewish writers place her home in Israel (through Wisdom and the Law). In Gnostic scripture she is give to explicitly reascend, as Pronoia in Ap. John via repentance and rehabilitation to the Pleroma, or, to the light, in the Hypostasis of the Archons.


 11) Sophia protected, delivered and strengthened Adam:
(Wis. 10:1) As Epinoia in the Ap. John, while it is perhaps unwise to directly identify Epinoia as an emanation of Sophia, this character ‘delivering him from his transgression ‘ saves Adam by enlightening him about his origin and destiny.


 12) Sophia is a ‘sister’:
(Prov. 7:4) In the Ap. John, ‘our sister Sophia’ appears numerous times. Iranaeus’ account of Sophia names her as the sister of the Aeon Christ.


 13) Sophia is associated with a sevenfold cosmic structure:
(Prov. 9:1) Jewish scripture here may refer to the seven pillared house of Wisdom – Excerpta ex Theodoto similarly proscribes a sevenfold Archonic structure.


 14) Sophia is identified with life:
(Prov 8:35, LXX Bar. 9:14) In Gnostic cosmogonies Sophia is linked with Zoe, the counterpart of Eve – sometimes as a daughter, sometimes called ‘Sophia Zoe’.


 15) Sophia is the tree of life:
(Prov 3:18, 1 Enoch 32:3) In Origin of the World both the tree of life and the tree of knowledge are good – although in Ap. John the tree of life is an evil instrument of the Archons.

I’m stunned by the variety and the paradox inherent in these roles of Sophia in Jewish and Gnostic literature – she is the bringer of both life and death, she is the first and the last, the protector, the revelation , and the protected, the revealed. All this, and I have yet to explore his argument, to be continued, next post.

The eternal breath of life, from the beginning and before.

Ref:
Macrae, GW. (1970). The Jewish Background of the Gnostic Sophia Myth, Novum Testamentum, 12:2, 86-101.

Sunday, May 23, 2010

Whitsunday MMX - Nexus Amorque, Spiritus Alme

Cuncipotens genitor Deus, omnicreator, eleison.
Salvificet pietas, tua nos, bone rector, eleison.
Kyrie eleison.

Christe, Dei splendor, virtus Patrisque sophia, eleison.
Plasmatis humani factor, lapsi reparator, eleison.
Christe eleison.

Amborum sacrum spiramen, nexus amorque, Spiritus alme.
Procedens virtus, vitae fons, largitor pie, Spiritus alme.
Consolatorque, sancto nos munere reple, eleison.
Kyrie eleison.




Great father God, all-creator, have mercy.
Mercy will save us, good governor, have mercy.
Lord, have mercy.

Christ, radiance of God, miraculous power, wisdom of the Father, have mercy.
Agent of human creation, redeemer of the Fall, have mercy.
Christ, have mercy.

Holy out-breath, conjunction and love of both, nurturing Spirit.
Miraculous power of coming forth, fount of life, benefactor, nurturing Spirit.
Consoler, fill us to the holy replete, have mercy.

Lord, have mercy.

Saturday, May 8, 2010

Ch 3 Women's Communities - 'The Emergence of Monasticism' by Marilyn Dunn

It is the feast day for Saint Pakhom tomorrow, May 9.

Pachomius is broadly recognised as the founder of Christian cenobitic life. Like St Antony, he recognised the need to provide care and safe harbour for his female relations - even within monastic life. The first female community was established by his sister, though very clearly, only single-sex communities were considered appropriate.

From the 350's a number of aristocratic Roman women begin to seek out the desert fathers. To become widowed was virtually the only way to achieve a kind of autonomy, although upper class women may have been expected to remarry for political alignment of families.

Marcella was an aristocrat who simply handed over all her possessions to her mother upon widowhood, and adopted an ascetic life, meeting only with monks and clergy. Paula and Melania the Elder are two other widows who follow suit, and who realised that to achieve a higher level of religious education they would need to consult with men - provincial clerics such as Rufinus and Jerome, who become their teachers. Jerome advised strict asceticism however, and somewhat of a scandal followed him, when Paula's daughter, Blesilla, a young and lively woman, dies from his strictures.

Melania the Elder is credited with founding a community of nuns at the Mount of Olives in 379, and is also the woman who persuades Evagrius of Pontus, at the time a cleric running from an unhappy love affair, to go to the ascetics in Egypt, launching him on the last stage of his spiritual odyssey. Evagrius writes his Sentences to a Virgin for Melania's community.

In particular, Sentences to a Virgin were written for a deaconess, Severa. Evagrius, despite his Origenist background, did take a gendered view of religious life, and does seem to have believed that women were incapable of achieving the same spiritual heights as men. Rather, Evagrius refers to the virgin as the 'Bride of Christ' where through her chastity the virgin will see, hear and touch her Bridgegroom. Thus does she become illuminated. Dunn charitably argues that Evagrius here attempts to combine his thesis of the union of a soul with God to the development of the virgin discourse, that become prevalent in the West through Ambrose and Jerome and Athanasius in the East. She does note that he completely avoids the term 'gnosis' in these Sentences.

Jerome later paints an idealised portrait of Paula's community - women who dressed plainly, ate simply, chanted psalms six times a day, and abstained from owning private property and from temptation in sexual desire, with fasts prescribed for the impudent. Interestingly, while these Roman aristocratic women seemed to embrace the simple plain life, hierarchies of groups according to social class were still used in the convent, and the women were not afraid to utilise their aristocratic connections in order to obtain funds for their various estates and good works.

Intriguingly, Palladius writes of Melania in glowing terms, that she read:

'every writing of the ancient commentators, including three million lines of Origen and two-and-a-half million lines of Gregory, Stephen, Pierius, Basil and the other standard writers. Nor did she read them once only and casually, but she laboriously went through each book seven or eight times.

Palladius says further of Melania:

'thanks to the grace of these books....elevated by kindly hopes she made herself a spiritual bird and journeyed to Christ'

reuniting the intellectual part of her soul, the logistikos, with God.

For Paula though, he observes darkly:

'She was hindered by a certain Jerome from Dalmatia, For though she was able to surpass all, having great abilities, he hindered her by his own jealousy having induced her to serve his own plan.'

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Salome, Sister and Disciple of Jesus

Watercolour by James Tissot, 1886-1896

Salome has a much greater role in the non-canonical texts than she does in the New Testament, yet surprisingly the pro-feminist stream that works it's way through modern gnosticism, as I understand it, seems to have left Salome by the wayside. I'm writing this essay as both a summary of Richard Bauckham's 1991 paper about Salome's role in scripture, and also to broaden my understanding of women's roles as they are presented in the gospels beyond the Virgin, the Magdalene and the Anointer (Mary, mother of God, Mary Magdalene and Mary of Bethany, respectively).

Salome is presented by Bauckham as having been portrayed in scripture in two key roles - that of a sister to Jesus, and that of a disciple to Jesus, the latter being a little more emphasised in the Eastern Orthodox tradition.

Regarding the role of sister, Ephanius names Salome and Mary as two sisters of Jesus, daughters of Joseph from his previous marriage. The Valentinian Gospel of Phillip also makes mention of 'a' sister in what is probably an allegorical reference to the gospel narratives to symbolise three feminine spiritual powers.

The Protoevangelium of James introduces the children of the family of Joseph as being present at the birth of Christ. Salome, witnessing the miracle of the virgin birth, makes her appearance here in a parallel to the role of Thomas the Disciple, witnessing the resurrected Christ. Salome meets Mary's midwife as she is leaving the birth-cave, and refuses to believe that the virgin has given birth until she can test Mary's condition with her finger. She touches Mary, and is burned. She prays, and an angel instructs her to touch the child, and she will find herself to be healed. She is told not to speak of these miracles that she has seen. In later Sahidic and Greek accounts Salome becomes either the midwife or another midwife in the story. According to the wonderfully names Discourse by Demetrius of Antioch on the Birth of our Lord:

'this woman Salome was the first who recognised the Christ, and who worshipped him, and believed in Him when He came upon the earth; and she did not return to her own house until the day of her death.'

Another late Coptic work, the Book of the Ressurection by Bartholemew, includes in the list of women who went to the tomb on Easter morning, 'Salome, who tempted Him'. Bauckham points to this as a reference to the Protoevangelium's account of Salome's unbelief (note that the Protoevangelium's account of the birth of Christ was probably suppressed under suspicion of Docetism).

In the canonical Gospels, Mark 15:40 and 16:1 both mention Salome as one of three disciples of Jesus in Galilee. She is one who watches the crucifixion and returns to the tomb on Easter morning. Bauckham looks at Matthew's tendency to drop other biblical characters that do appear in Mark (for example Alexander and Rufus) and proposes that Salome simply was not known in Matthew's church. Luke's women are all anonymous, at the cross, at the burial and at the tomb. He retrospectively names some of them in further chapters. The Evangelist considers no other women besides Mary Magdalene in his account of the crucifixion - the Virgin is mentioned briefly, under the cross.

The Gnostic Sophia of Jesus Christ  and the First Apocalypse of James both report seven disciples for Jesus - although in all of the apocrypha only six women are named - the Magdalene, Martha, Salome, Arsinoe, the Virgin and Mary, the sister of Jesus. Salome also appears in the role of interlocutor to Jesus in four Gnostic works - Gospel of the Egyptians, the Gospel of Thomas, the Pistis Sophia and the Syriac Testament to our Lord.

The conversation in the Gospel of the Egyptians  portrays an encratite view of a salvation of humanity to a state without sexual differentiation. In the Gospel of Thomas conversation, too, Salome is presented in a conversation about transcending sexual differentiation in order to return to original unity. In the Pistis Sophia Salome is portrayed as framing the questions which the Magdalene answers.

Salome is presented as a source of esoteric tradition - the 'H[C]arpocratians of Salome' are listed by Celsus as carriers of an esoteric tradition, that is guessed by Bauckham to have once had a considerable volume of teachings, given the peculiar Carpocratian theology, now lost. Her prominence in the Egyptian Gospel traditions would have rendered her highly suitable as an authority for a claim to a tradition passed down by Jesus.

The non-Gnostic Testament of our Lord lists Salome as one of the women disciples among Mary and Martha who are given ministry by Jesus [excuse me a minute, the hairs on the back of my neck just stood up].

So I'll cover off the Secret Gospel of Mark and summarise the paper in another post, but this post, in particular, quietly announces:

The Oratory of Salome the Disciple, of the Gnostic Church of St Mary Magdalene, Sydney, Australia.


Let's see how we go.

Ref:

Bauckham, R. (1991). Salome the Sister of Jesus, Salome the Disciple of Jesus and the Secret Gospel of Mark. Novum Testamentum. XXXIII, 3, 245-275.

Saturday, March 20, 2010

St Radegund, Queen and Nun

I interrupt this oh-so-well-paced meander through 'The Emergence of Monasticism' (as I have, many a time already) to bring you a quick preview of a few centuries onward and a few leagues northward in time and space, introducing you to the spector of St Radegund, queen, deacon and nun. She has a feast day in the Latin Rite, of August 13 each year. 


Radegund was a Thuriginian (German) princess who was captured with her brother at the battle of Berscheidungen in 531 and was kept hostage by Frankish King Clothar until she was of marriageable age. She was educated in the catholic faith and in Latin, and although she was married to Clothar at age 15 she never bore any children, instead devoting her life to religious and charitable work.


Eventually, around 550, she learns that Clothar had ordered the murder of her brother, at which point she abandons the court completely and approaches Bishop Medard of Noyon to consecrate her as a deacon. Initially living a life of severe austerity she gathers a community about her and then establishes a convent, the nunnery of the Holy Cross, in 561. Clothar sees his own death approaching, and assists his queen to establish foundations for the convent. Radegund never ruled the convent herself, rather she installs Agnes, her spiritual daughter, as abbess. 


She has two hagiographers - Venantius Fortunatus, Italian poet and eventually a bishop, and Baudonivia, one of the nuns in her convent. Both emphasise her charity and unceasing work for the poor and sick. Fortunatus emphasises her bodily mortifications - including descriptions of Radegund branding herself with a heated up brass plate of the cross and forcing herself to carry a basin of hot coals. His poetry describes a very different Radegund, and we hear of delightful supper parties and his companionship with her as a lover of literature and of learning.


Baudonivia describes Radegund's energy and fidelity in intercession, prayer and charity. Through Baudovinia, Radegund is portrayed as being central within Frankish royal politics, but as a woman who also represents the feminine values of intercession and peacemaking, and who too had a humble role in domestic tasks around the nunnery - a representation of asceticism and sanctity which contrasts with the ideal of the 'manly' women characteristic of the earliest days of monasticism.


Her story reads like mythology, to me, and I take her example to heart. We're about to enter Passiontide, and the hymns of Passiontide, still used in the Latin rite today, are the work Saint Venantius Fortunatus, composed for the reception of some relics of the True Cross, which Queen Radegund received as a gift from the Byzantine Emperor and installed in the monastery of the Holy Cross.


A reason to remember, and a cause to be inspired. St Radegund, queen, nun and deacon.